Stories through Unexpected Ideas
The language of stories in video games often mirrors those of film and television. Cutscenes, the ubiquitous option for delivering big narrative moments recall those found in your average prestige piece, from camera angles, shot design, lighting & color schemes as well as liberal use of visual storytelling over dialogue in more experimental indie-centric titles. Intro sequences (Far Cry 6 comes to mind) highlighting the title's key visuals in the vein of prestige intros. You'd be hard pressed to find a AAA game that doesn't take some visual language from the world of cinema.
And yet what continues to separate games from other visual mediums on the market is its elements of interactability and the player's participation in the ongoing narrative, whether shaping it implicitly (adding their own meaning to a vague tale) or explicitly (branching stories). The difference simply comes down to whose authorship is in command throughout the game. For system-centric games, this isn't much of an issue. Those same systems can spit out an infinite number of dynamic stories, such as Shadow of Mordor's Nemesis system or XCOM's perishable grunts. For more controlled and authored stories, this is an albatross hanging over the whole enterprise. How does one preserve that player agency while retaining our own over the narrative we wish to tell?

We have approached the challenge in a couple of ways. Most would be familiar with QTE sequences, in places such as God of War, Asura's Wrath & the Order: 1886. QTEs require the player to press, hold down or mash a button or series of buttons at the right time to avoid failing the sequence or lead to a bad scenario outcome. In narrative-heavy games such as Telltale Games' episodic collection, QTEs serve a vital purpose in maintaining interactivity in otherwise linear action scenes to contrast against its core choice-drive dialogue scenes. However, going too far in the other direction can leave players feeling uninvolved as if watching someone else have all the fun. In the case of the Order: 1886, the QTE boss fight sections stand in too stark of a contrast with the core gameplay's cover based shooting against human foes, making the game feel at once unique and generic at the same time.

The other method, on-rails sections found in titles such as the original Dead Space, Call of Duty and Gears of War tend to be utilized as palate cleansers, breaking up the flow of standard combat encounters to provide players with a new experience. General on-rail sequences tend to be of the turret or hazard variety, tasking players to fend off waves of enemies/objects with a mounted turret or avoiding hazards in their path. These sections generally have simple 'escape the threat' story beats, but lacks the space to convey any more beyond the immediate anxiety of the situation, like empty calories that are filling yet forgettable. If not those methods, what then can we use? By leaning on one other aspect that differs us from film and television. See, almost every game uses a HUD (Heads Up Display) to convey certain information to the player in a quick and legible manner such as the player's current health and resources & map markers for easy navigation. The trick is to take that existing visual language and leverage it to convey a twist, a character's emotion or even to accentuate an ongoing cutscene, all without potentially having to wrench player control entirely out of their hand. What It Says On The Bar Of course, even in this category one such implementation has become its own trope, that of using health bars (HP) as shorthand to indicate a character's state during key moments.
Take Clair Obscur: Expedition 33 in which without entirely spoiling the scene, the player watches the current main character suffer through fatal wounds, vainly guiding their last attempts at resistance in gameplay. Or perhaps Call of Duty, king of using jam splotches and slow blurring viewpoints in cutscenes to indicate that the POV character has taken a fatal wound as quite a few are prone to do over the course of the series. To a lesser extent, Dead Space 2's ending moments do lean on this though their implementation is less than ideal as it simply sets the bar straight to near empty on the first hit rather than incrementally over the two hits the protagonist takes.

Destiny 2's Red War campaign (1) (shout out to anyone who played early days Destiny 2 before it was vaulted) also includes a whole sequence where the player bereft of the Light that allows them to be revived must stumble through the ruins of the City to find safe harbor elsewhere. That sequence includes both a severely depleted health bar and a UI icon indicating no revivals to hammer home the point. As mentioned, it's hardly a novel implementation but effective nonetheless. Pattern Disruption Sometimes, it's as simple as disrupting the core loop or expected behavior of the main game to indicate a core emotional moment or to lead into a shocking twist. Halo: Reach's (2) final objective is simply to survive as long as possible, but as the player takes damage to their core health, their helmet starts to display cracks. This is in stark contrast to how the game has played before, a simple tweak that instantly gets across the doomed nature of your character. Another example is Final Fantasy: Crisis Core where one of its mechanics involves a slot machine that uses characters befriended by the main protagonist as its faces. In the finale, that slot machine starts to glitch out with most characters being erased until only one last character, that of a girl who has become important to him. This helps to indicate where the main protagonist's final thoughts are at.

Another example comes near the beginning of God of War: Ragnarok (3) as Kratos battles against Thor, the God of Thunder. As gameplay ensues, the game shifts to a QTE sequence, the kind often seen in series past. Yet the QTE seemingly ends in failure as Kratos takes a fatal blow from Thor and the game plays its loading screen as if prepared to restart from the last checkpoint. And yet two things tweak as to the twist that this was all pre-planned. One, there is no text in the tooltip, an unlikely oversight given its early placement on a likely well-tested title. (All devs know why beginnings are generally more polished than endings) Secondly, Thor's voice quickly interjects to say that he's not allowing this 'death' to stand. The use of UI rather than staying with the action both serves its gameplay as a momentum breather and makes the twist land, even if it doesn't last long enough to linger in the mind.

One final example can be found in Star Wars Jedi Survivor (4), where all bosses will display both their name and their health bar upon being introduced, alerting players to the incoming fight. This particular boss comes at the tail end of a grueling encounter, one where players are likely exhausted, out of resources and likely searching for a checkpoint to recuperate. What seems like a weird time to place a boss fight becomes a moment of relief and hilarity when the game reveals that the 'boss' fight is naught but a standard grunt in disguise. While this is not commented on in any narrative manner, its impact and its subsequent virality amongst players indicates that it can generate memorable moments done right.
Write In Their Voice
Expressing basic text in unique ways can also highlight emotions or information without resorting to overly written sentences. For instance, applying camera shake effects to incoming text can sell the emotion of anger of a character in a quickfire manner, allowing the actual line to hone in on other details instead. Corrupted text effects can indicate the speaker's medium of choice (i.e. speaker) may not be working correctly. Blurring or outright black bars can be both a way to prevent your game from getting a high age rating and serve as an effective punchline to a given joke. This particular method is generally reserved for smaller indie titles as its implementation can potentially clash against the title's art style and themes, but it can really elevate a moment when done well.
Summary
So, while there will be times where the narrative of the moment calls for that well crafted cutscene, a dynamic dialogue moment or perhaps even a QTE sequence to better convey those beats, consider how simply tweaking around with the UI widgets at the heart of the game might just become your next 2-for-1 deal. Surprise
Until next time, stay safe and keep overthinking! References
1.) Sequence described in Destiny 2's Red War campaign. (https://youtu.be/fIhXR63GsGI?t=1290)
2.) Sequence described in Halo: Reach's finale. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XQUBlx-u284)
3.) Sequence described in God of War: Ragnarok. (https://youtu.be/ixllGOX0Evw?t=3033)
4.) Boss fight in full in Star Wars Jedi Survivor. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nOcLkkEvBCY)



Comments